If you like my books, essays, etc. you might want to put your name on this private email list (no spam ever) for advance notices, coupons, and occasional freebies. Tell your friends too! Books Leaving Footprints Newsletter. Previous gifts include a short story, a poem and a half-off coupon for the newest book. Sign up, and don't miss out!"

Friday, February 18, 2011

When Watson is Stupid...


For the past two days, I've been talking about the historic Jeopardy match between Watson, the IBM computer, and Ken Jennings and Brad Rutter. One of the most interesting goofs that Watson made was in Final Jeopardy of the first of the two games.

Jeopardy match Watson, Ken Jennings, Brad Rutter

As you can see, the category was "US Cities," and the answer was "Its largest airport is named for a World War II hero; its second largest, for a World War II battle."

If you haven't already seen this, you have 30 seconds to think of the question..."Da, duh, da, duh..." you know the tune.

So how did you go about trying to figure this out? You might have started with trying to remember commonly-known names of large US airports: Reagan (Washington), Kennedy (New York), Ford (Grand Rapids, MI), O'Hare (Chicago), Logan (Boston), Armstrong (New Orleans). Then you might have asked yourself which of those people were WW II heroes. So now we are down to Kennedy, and O'Hare, maybe Ford. Grand Rapids only has one airport. What are the other airports in New York? LaGuardia- doesn't sound like a battle. What are the other airports in Chicago? Midway- there you go! write fast... "What is Chicago?"

Ken did.

Jeopardy match Watson, Ken Jennings, Brad Rutter

Brad did.

Jeopardy match Watson, Ken Jennings, Brad Rutter

Watson...

Jeopardy match Watson, Ken Jennings, Brad Rutter

... wrote "What is Toronto?" What?! Somehow Watson forgot to run his lists of comparisons against cities in the United States! But, it didn't matter. You would think that the machine would have had more self confidence, but it only bet $937. Phooey. So, it clobbered the humans, big time, in Game 1.


See John Henry of the 21st Century- Part 2
See John Henry of the 21st Century- Part 1


8 comments:

Ratty said...

These posts have been very interesting. I could read stuff like this for a long time. At least Watson seems to know when it's not quite on track. I'd bet it also doesn't have the ability to speculate on what others might be thinking, like most humans do. That would be a next valuable step in Watson's evolution if it hasn't already begun.

Ann said...

LOL is this computer blond? I wouldn't have been able to come up with the right answer but I at least know that Toronto isn't a US city

sir rob said...

Sounds interesting but Watson is funny. OR was he just cracking a joke? LOL

Mike Golch said...

it clobbered the humans,Period.what scares me is that here should be limits on how far they can go.before the programming/creation of supercomputer go.

vanilla said...

--and yet I got a guffaw out of it. Using your approach the other evening, I think I figured it out in about 19 seconds. Yeah, I'm a bit slow.

Sharkbytes said...

Ratty- maybe it's an advantage to NOT react to what others are thinking.

Ann- Watson seems to be weakest on checking the clue list that one would get from the category. I have one more post to do on this topic.

sir rob- It sure wasn't trying to joke. I don't know if it knows how

vanilla- you had 30 secs for final Jeopardy, so you would have been fine!

RNSANE said...

I still liked the humans better. Watson lack personality.

Sharkbytes said...

Carmen- I like Ken. Brad annoys me.

Related Posts Widget for Blogs by LinkWithin